All commentary

The Pacific Lens

Uninhabitable by 2100: The Phrase That Erases a People

The Marshall Islands is named among five nations that may be 'uninhabitable' by century's end. The warning is necessary. The word is not — and the Pacific deserves better answers than sympathy.

3 min read

At the United Nations General Assembly in 2024, the Secretary-General delivered what the press called a warning about a “rising tide of misery.” The science behind it was stark: global mean sea level at a record high, the rate of rise over the last decade more than double what it was between 1993 and 2002, and an IPCC-cited study naming five countries — the Maldives, Tuvalu, the Marshall Islands, Nauru, and Kiribati — that could become uninhabitable by 2100. The figure that followed: six hundred thousand people made stateless by the sea.

Al Jazeera’s coverage was sober and necessary. Every word of the warning is true, and the Marshall Islands sits squarely inside it. This is our family’s future being described in a conference room in New York. We have heard this speech before, in one form or another, since the 1980s.

The word that does the damage

What deserves a second look is the vocabulary. “Uninhabitable” and “stateless” are words chosen in capitals far from the lagoons they describe, and they carry their own quiet danger. They write a people out of the future in advance. They turn a nation into a problem to be managed — an evacuation plan to be filed, a number to be relocated — rather than a sovereignty to be defended.

Here is what the language misses: a nation is not a coastline. The Marshall Islands will still be a nation at 2100 whatever the sea does, because sovereignty does not dissolve with the tide line. Maritime boundaries persist. Cultures persist. The government of a flooded atoll is still a government. What “stateless” really describes is a failure of the world to treat people who had no hand in the crisis as equal partners in solving it.

Migration is not surrender

There is also a story the coverage barely reaches: the Pacific has already built its own adaptive infrastructure. The Compacts of Free Association — the same agreements that fund clinics and roads — let Marshallese and Micronesians live and work in the United States without visas. That is not an evacuation plan. It is a network of belonging stretched across an ocean, proof that this region does not wait for the world to rescue it. Communities in Arkansas, in Hawaii, in Oregon are not refugee camps; they are Micronesia extended.

What the region asks for

The Pacific does not need more warnings. Every summit produces them, and they change little. What the region needs is what it has asked for for thirty years: the countries that caused the crisis to cut the emissions driving it; the loss-and-damage money to be delivered, not promised; and a seat at the table where the answers are actually decided — not a slot in the audience where our fate is announced.

The phrase “uninhabitable by 2100” erases a people by writing their future off. The Pacific’s answer has never changed. We are not leaving. We are not giving up. We are asking the world to act as though the future matters — because the islands are only the first place it will arrive.

Based on

Coastal communities face 'catastrophic flooding' from rising sea levels

Al Jazeera · September 28, 2024

Read the original article

This commentary was drafted with AI assistance and reviewed by an editor before publishing.